Chapter 7
A research programme applied to the conservation of the great hammerhead shark in the Tuamotu islands.
They saw it up close, very close indeed, and on several occasions. It came to them naturally, driven by instinct and curiosity. It showed itself to remind them that it existed, then left as discreetly as it had come, into the ocean depths.
It was a furtive encounter, a powerful interaction that brought both happiness and concern and which, like their previous ones, will remain engraved in the two divers’ memories. They have reached their objective, their work is now done and every minute counts at this great depth. It’s time for them to go back up.
They allow themselves to be carried back by the current to a small underwater cave, a convenient refuge where they will spend their long hours of essential decompression before returning to the surface. A parachute buoy is sent out by one of the divers to inform the boat’s crew that they have finished their dive safely. It is also the signal for the second pair of divers, who had remained on board, to get into the water to take over operations. But first, the boat’s pilot, who is well-versed in the procedure, carefully retrieves the underwater speargun and the small bottle attached to the buoy by the divers. The gesture is quick but meticulous, because he knows that the bottle contains a very precious sample.
In their small cave, a few metres below the surface and sheltered from the current, the two divers now have time on their hands. Sitting on a small slab of dead coral, they observe the landscape before them. The cave overlooks a narrow coral canyon through which an array of multicoloured fish with evocative names parade: rainbow runners, parrotfish, butterflyfish, lionfish, blues potted groupers, spotted eagle rays and blacktip reef sharks. The beauty of the scenery is breathtaking, all the more so as everyone in this small gathering seems oblivious to the presence, albeit discreet, of the two divers. Before their eyes, underwater life is in full swing. Silent witnesses to a natural symphony in perpetual motion, the divers admire the delicate balance of this wilderness, where every element, from the tiniest marine creature to the vast coral reefs, occupies a vital place in this ecosystem and contributes to maintaining its health and resilience.
But the divers are not fooled: they know that a shadow hangs over the harmony of this underwater composition. A cloud that continues to darken, a global ecological crisis that threatens this fragile equilibrium a little more each day and of which one of the most alarming signs is the continuing decline in biodiversity. They have ringside seats to this situation. Not there, sitting in the cave in front of this teeming crowd, but just before, when, in the depths of the ocean, they were lucky enough to encounter one of its sadly emblematic ambassadors: the great hammerhead shark.
The two divers, dressed all in red, are scientists and members of Gombessa Expeditions led by marine biologist and photographer Laurent Ballesta. When they emerge from the water in a few hours’ time, they will join the other members of the team at their research base facing the immense lagoon of the Rangiroa atoll, in French Polynesia’s Tuamotu archipelago. It is here, in this remote corner of the Pacific Ocean, that they and members of the local Mokarran Protection Society – with Blancpain’s unfailing support through its Blancpain Ocean Commitment initiative – are conducting one of the most ambitious research programmes ever dedicated to the preservation of this shark on the brink of extinction: the TAMATAROA project, named after the great hammerhead shark in the local dialect.
Designed to take place over four years, the programme has ambitious yet necessary objectives: to provide scientific knowledge, identify pressures, define conservation issues and foster citizen involvement to support the implementation of sustainable management measures adapted to the conservation of the great hammerhead shark and its habitats in French Polynesia.
The story of this animal, the mysteries surrounding it and the genesis of this project are expertly outlined by Tatiana Boube in her article published in the previous edition of Lettres du Brassus in 2023. Tatiana, a marine biologist based in French Polynesia, received a grant from Blancpain to support her doctoral studies and research on the great hammerhead shark at the University of French Polynesia. A year and a half after its launch, the considerable efforts deployed as part of this programme are beginning to bear fruit and are now a veritable source of hope for the preservation of this species and its environment.
Over the last year and a half, scientific divers from Gombessa Expeditions and volunteer members of the Mokarran Protection Society have worked tirelessly to implement the programme’s numerous scientific protocols. In order to introduce effective conservation measures designed to halt the decline of this magnificent shark, the first step involves answering questions about its ecology, the needs associated with its survival and the threats to its equilibrium:
· What are the characteristics of the great hammerhead shark population in this region of the Pacific? Is it different from other known populations?
· Where, when and how does it feed? What species does it target in its diet?
· Where, when and how is it evolving? What is its range?
· Where, when and how does it reproduce? What are its preferred locations for giving birth and raising its young?
· What human and/or natural pressures and threats affect each phase of its life cycle?
To answer these questions, the TAMATAROA programme uses a holistic and integrative approach that combines scientific, participatory, cultural and awareness-raising initiatives and collaboration with marine environment management institutions. The teams thus conduct their work both on land in contact with local populations, and underwater in direct contact with the great hammerhead shark.
In the villages and remote areas of the Rangiroa atoll, the actions implemented aim to encourage the active participation of citizens and promote collective awareness of the issues involved in preserving the great hammerhead shark and its environment. This approach involves setting up citizen surveys and creating and running a participatory science programme. The data collected makes it possible to integrate local knowledge of this species with the socio-economic and cultural dimensions that are inseparable from the management of marine environments. Such information thus contributes to a better understanding of the dynamics of marine ecosystems and the conservation challenges facing the great hammerhead shark in French Polynesia, all the while encouraging participatory and responsible management of the area’s ecological treasures.
These participatory approaches are supported by awareness-raising initiatives carried out on an almost daily basis, through workshops, talks, educational campaigns and community events designed to inform and mobilise a wide audience. The highlight of this action is an international documentary that is currently being made to complement the existing ‘Gombessa’ films. It will showcase this scientific and participatory project using never-before-seen underwater footage to convey the cultural and ecological wealth of the Tuamotu atolls.
Alongside these actions, the programme also incorporates a crucially important cultural aspect. French Polynesia is imbued with rich cultural diversity, ancestral traditions and unique practices that are notably manifested through a deep connection between human beings and the natural world. By highlighting these ties, this initiative is leading to more inclusive scientific research that will provide a better understanding of, and help preserve, the delicate balance between local communities and their environment, while leveraging traditional knowledge to promote sustainability and the conservation of these natural resources.
Underwater, in the depths of the Tiputa Pass, the main observation site for the great hammerhead shark in the Rangiroa atoll, pairs of divers take it in turns to patiently unravel the mysteries of the great hammerhead shark’s ecology for months at a time. It is during these long, deep dives that, when luck is on their side, they manage to get close to this mysterious predator living on borrowed time.
Equipped with their SMART system (see explanation on page 75), they attempt to identify and measure the individuals observed at each encounter. This data will be used to describe the great hammer head shark population in Polynesia by determining the number of individuals observed, the ratio of males to females and their stage of maturity, backed by genetic analysis of skin tissue samples taken from the animals. The results will soon make it possible to estimate the structure and connectivity of the populations, their size, as well as certain reproductive behaviours.
These samples will also be used to define the species’ diet. The survival of a predator is closely linked to its ability to find food and therefore on the abundance of prey available in its environment. To identify the nature of this prey, as well as the places and times when the great hammerhead shark feeds, the team is using a new scientific method called ‘stable isotope analysis’. This innovative technique is based on the principle that ‘we are what we eat’. It makes it possible to trace the feeding habits of sharks through a ‘simple’ analysis of the isotopic composition of their muscle tissue. Stable isotopes, which are naturally present in the environment, are absorbed by marine organisms through their diet. By studying the ratios of these isotopes in great hammerhead shark tissue samples, valuable information can be obtained about the types of prey they consume and the different habitats they frequent.
The tracking tags that experienced divers are able to attach to sharks should make it possible to define their migratory routes and correlate them with their primary survival needs. Two types of tag are being deployed under the SMART system: ‘acoustic’ tags and ‘data archiving’ tags. Both are designed to track the movements of pelagic species that have little or no surface presence. The first kind of tag is the size of a pen and emits a regular acoustic signal specific to each tagged individual. This signal can be picked up by acoustic receivers fixed in advance at strategic points in the lagoon and its passes, so as to create invisible listening fields. The acoustic signals they pick up when a tagged shark passes close by can be used to identify the individual as well as the time and date of its passage. To obtain a precise idea of the movements of sharks within the Rangiroa lagoon, the team has deployed the largest underwater acoustic network in the central Pacific.
‘Data archiving’ tags, meanwhile, are used to track major migrations in offshore areas. These are small, highly sophisticated satellite transmitters that continuously record data on depth, temperature and luminosity. Attached to the sharks for a pre-programmed period, they are eventually released automatically and return to the surface to transmit all the data they have stored via the Argos satellite system. By combining the data they record, mathematical models can be used to trace the movements of the individuals being tracked on a very large scale and in three dimensions.
Throughout their migratory journey, great hammerhead sharks pass through a variety of underwater habitats. While some are merely travel corridors, others can play crucial roles for the species as feeding, reproduction, calving or nursery sites. It is these habitats that scientists are seeking to identify using dedicated protocols: counting potential prey, searching for juveniles, studying behaviour, etc. To do this, they conduct diving campaigns wherever sharks tend to linger. Each time an area of interest is identified, the scientists look at its ecological health and the various pressures that humans are likely to exert on it through their activities. This is where management measures will eventually be focused, to encourage those who use marine environments to adopt eco-responsible stances and contribute to the ecological transition of their activities by implementing more sustainable approaches.
The fact that the great hammerhead shark, which is emblematic of Polynesian waters, has never previously been studied in this part of the world speaks volumes about the considerable scientific and technical challenges involved.
To study discreet, shy marine animals such as sharks, conventional scientific methods consist in attracting them with bait and capturing them alive for the time required to study them (identification, measurements, taking samples, tagging, etc.), before releasing them. However, animals caught in this way are subjected to a high level of stress which – in the case of certain fragile species such as the great hammerhead shark – can be fatal. Despite the risks to the animals, this method is still widely used in other parts of the world, unfortunately with significant losses for this critically endangered species.
This conventional method, which often entails intensive baiting techniques, can also lead to changes in the behaviour of the animals monitored. The abundance of easily and regularly accessible food can lead to habituation, which can modify migratory routes and create loyalty to the feeding site. Also used in shark watching, these baiting methods are becoming increasingly controversial, to the point where French Polynesia decided to ban them completely in 2017.
To study the great hammerhead shark without using this method deemed too detrimental to the animal’s survival, the Gombessa Expeditions team has devised a protocol based on a new technical, scientific and ethical approach. This involves not attracting the animal to the scientist, but instead going to meet it in situ without using any baiting in order to conduct all the scientific monitoring protocols in the least invasive way possible, without constraining the animal or modifying its behaviour. To achieve this, the new method is based on extensive knowledge of the field and the development of an innovative ‘all-in-one’ tool known as the SMART (Shark Monitoring And Research Tool) system.
Developed by scientists from Gombessa Expeditions, this system features an underwater speargun specially designed to meet the specific needs and constraints of the TAMATAROA programme. It is equipped with a camera for identifying the individuals observed, a laser plate for measuring their size at a distance and a special arrowhead designed to penetrate just a few centimetres of the shark’s skin in order to attach a tracking tag and take a small sample of skin tissue.
The design of this novel arrowhead – on which the success of a large part of the monitoring protocols depends – was a real technical challenge. To make their concept a reality, the Gombessa team naturally turned to Blancpain, its long-standing expedition partner. Passionate and always keen to support research and environmental conservation initiatives, the Blancpain teams drew on their excellent expertise in high-precision engineering to create this multifunctional, surgically precise instrument.
This system enables divers to conduct all the monitoring proto- cols in the very short time available to them during their natural, close interactions with the sharks. It offers an alternative to conventional baiting and capture methods while paving the way for study protocols that are less invasive and more respectful of these large predators.
USING THE SMART SYSTEM
At every encounter, the divers are filled with excitement, albeit barely palpable given how focused they are on their scientific objectives. For they know that the success of their scientific programme depends largely on the success of their mission, conducted 60 metres below the surface in the face of this majestic animal. Positioned on the seabed, the diver equipped with his SMART system films the animal, which is curious and approaches him calmly. Later on, these images will reveal the small physical details that are unique to this individual’s body and that will be used to identify it. Coming within just a few metres of the diver, the shark – whose curiosity appears to be whetted by the encounter – turns slowly to avoid him. The two green dots projected by the lasers are clearly visible on its flank. Exactly 30 cm apart, they will be used to determine its size when the images are processed. But the diver isn’t looking at them. He is concentrating on his shot, which must be extremely accurate. The arrow shoots out, penetrates a few centimetres under the fin, then falls back to the ground. Inside its fine hollow point, a small sample of skin has just been taken. The action only lasted a tenth of a second. Barely affected by the sting, the shark continues on its way into the darkness of the deep. From a distance, the divers can see a small black spot on its back. This is the tag now attached to the shark that will enable them to track its long migration.
The great hammerhead shark is a symbol of the erosion of under water biodiversity and a victim of the ongoing degradation of habitats and resource depletion. It is also on the brink of extinction. There is, however, a glimmer of hope in the middle of the Pacific Ocean. By focusing conservation efforts in this region of the world, the TAMATAROA programme is emerging as an essential and ambitious initiative to safeguard this species in a part of the world that could be one of its last refuges.
The TAMATAROA programme is being built and run in close collaboration with the Rangiroa municipality, French Polynesia’s Department of the Environment, the French Biodiversity Agency (OFB) and the High Commission of the Republic in French Polynesia. As well as providing financial backing for the project, these public institutions give technical and political support, which is essential if it is to succeed, particularly in the context of future participative and integrative management of the great hammerhead shark, its habitats and its resources in French Polynesia.